Artificial Sweeteners vs. Sugar in Soda: Which Is Safer?

Artificial Sweeteners vs. Sugar in Soda: Which Is Safer?

Soda has long been a popular beverage choice for both children and adults alike. Who doesn't love the satisfying fizz and rush of flavor from a cold, bubbly soft drink? However, concerns over the health effects of soda have many people switching from regular to diet versions in an effort to cut calories and sugar. But are artificial sweeteners really any safer than good old fashioned sugar? Let's take a closer look at this hotly debated topic.

Artificial Sweeteners: Too Good to Be True?

With public health officials constantly warning about obesity and diabetes epidemics, it's no wonder that artificial sweeteners sound incredibly appealing. They provide the sweet taste we crave without any of those nasty calories, making them seem like they offer the best of both worlds. Some of the most popular artificial sweeteners used in diet sodas and other sugar-free beverages include:

Aspartame: Aspartame has been used in diet sodas since the 1980s. It provides a very sweet taste without calories or carbohydrates.

Sucralose: This synthetic compoun is made from sugar but is chemically altered so the body cannot metabolize it. It's about 600 times sweeter than regular sugar.

Acesulfame potassium: Often blended with other sweeteners, acesulfame potassium (or Ace-K) enhances sweetness while also helping diet sodas maintain their fizz and shelf stability.

Advantame: Approved for use by the FDA in 2014, advantame is an ultra-potent sweetener derived from aspartame. It's approximately 20,000 times sweeter than sugar.

Neotame: Very similar to aspartame, but with a more intense sweet flavor. It's used in very small amounts as a sweetener and flavor enhancer.

With no calories, carbs, or blood sugar impact, artificial sweeteners seem like they should be the perfect solution for enjoying sweet drinks without the downsides of sugar. But are they truly as safe for our health as they seem? Let's explore some of the debated risks.

Potential Health Risks of Artificial Sweeteners

While agencies like the FDA have approved artificial sweeteners as safe for consumption, some health advocates have raised concerns over potential risks:

Cancer Concerns

One of the most worrisome allegations against artificial sweeteners is that they may be linked to certain types of cancer. For example, some controversial studies found that rats fed very high doses of aspartame over their lifetimes were more likely to develop cancers of the brain, liver, and pelvis. However, other animal studies have not found evidence of increased cancer risk, even at high consumption levels. Reviews of human population data have also found no clear association between aspartame and cancer. While more research may be needed, the majority of evidence seems to suggest little to no cancer risk in humans at typical intake levels.

Effects on Gut Health and Microbiome

There is emerging evidence that regular consumption of artificial sweeteners may negatively impact the balance of bacteria in our digestive systems, known as the gut microbiome. Animal studies suggest sweeteners like saccharin and sucralose can interfere with proper gut functioning and may trigger inflammatory processes. More human research is still needed, but maintaining gut health is extremely important for overall well-being.

Interfering with Appetite Signals and Metabolism

Although artificial sweeteners are very low in calories, research suggests they may still be able to stimulate the release of insulin in our bodies. This can essentially "trick" the appetite control centers in our brain, leading to increased hunger signals and a higher propensity for weight gain. There is also evidence from animal studies that frequent artificial sweetener use may disrupt healthy metabolic function over time by altering gut bacteria.

Toxicity at High Doses

While approved artificial sweeteners are considered safe at typical dosage levels, extremely high quantities can potentially have toxic effects in humans. For example, overconsumption of aspartame is associated with headaches, dizziness, mood changes, and even seizures. However, these levels are very difficult to reach through diet alone under normal circumstances.

So while more research may still be needed, there is no clear scientific consensus that artificial sweeteners pose imminent health risks for the general population. However, unanswered questions remain. Are newer sweeteners like advantame as safe as older ones like aspartame that have been more widely studied? And what happens when artificial sweeteners are consumed in large amounts on a daily basis over a lifetime?

Sugar's Not-So-Sweet Effects

If the potential risks of artificial sweeteners leave you skeptical, you may think sticking with regular sugar is the safer choice. After all, it's natural, right? Unfortunately, loading up on the sugar found in regular sodas comes with its own list of health drawbacks:

High calorie content: A 12-oz can of non-diet soda typically contains around 130 calories, almost all from sugar. This can add up fast, increasing risks of obesity, diabetes, and heart disease.
Tooth decay and dental issues: The sugars in soda feed oral bacteria that produce acids that attack enamel and cause cavities and tooth decay, especially when sipped frequently throughout the day.
Sugar crash and energy spikes: The blood sugar spike and ensuing crash from high sugar intake can lead to fatigue, irritability, and trouble concentrating.
Contributes to obesity, diabetes, and heart disease: Excessive sugar intake is strongly associated with weight gain and higher risks of metabolic diseases. Over time it can also accelerate aging.
Addictive qualities: Sugar stimulates the reward centers in the brain, which can trigger cravings and addictive-like behaviors. This makes soda very hard to consume in moderation for many people.

So while sugar is natural, its health effects are anything but. When consumed in high amounts on a regular basis, the risks clearly add up. But does this mean artificial sweeteners are necessarily the safer choice?

Are Artificial Sweeteners Really Safer Than Sugar?

When it comes to the great soda debate over artificial sweeteners compared to sugar, there are decent arguments on both sides. Here are some key things to consider when deciding which may be safer for your individual health:

Lack of long-term studies: Many artificial sweeteners like advantame are relatively new, so their effects from decades of human consumption are unknown.
Mixed evidence on cancer risk: While links between artificial sweeteners and cancer in humans remain unproven, neither can they be conclusively ruled out based on current data.
Still affect insulin response: Even without calories, artificial sweeteners can trigger insulin release which may disrupt appetite signals.
Sugar has downsides but is natural: Despite concerns, sugar exists in nature and has been consumed for millennia, so complete avoidance may be an overreaction.
Individual differences in response: Genetic and metabolic differences mean some people may be more susceptible to harm from artificial sweeteners or sugar.

The reality is that research remains unclear whether artificial sweeteners are definitively safer than sugar for everyone. As with most things, dosage and frequency matter. Consuming an occasional diet soda sweetened with sucralose or aspartame is very different from drinking multiple cans daily for months or years.

Is Diet Soda Better Than Regular Soda?

One of the most frequently asked questions when it comes to sodas is whether diet soda is better for you than regular soda. Here are some key considerations:

Lower calorie count: Diet sodas have zero calories, while regular sodas average about 150 calories per 12oz can. This makes diet seemingly better for weight management.
Artificial sweetener concerns: While diet sodas have no sugar, the long-term impact of artificial sweeteners on health remains unclear. Moderation is key.
Other ingredients: Diet and regular soda both contain carbonated water, caramel coloring, phosphoric acid, natural flavors, and caffeine. Many of the same concerns around processing and additives apply to both.
Taste preference: Some studies show people find the taste of artificial sweeteners in diet soda less satisfying than real sugar. This can lead to drinking more.
Availability: Diet sodas are readily available in stores and restaurants. For managing calories during social situations or meals out, they can be a better option than sugary drinks.

Overall, while neither may be a true health drink, diet sodas are likely a better alternative than full-sugar regular soda, if consumed in moderation. But lowering intake of all sugary beverages and focusing on more natural, nutritious choices is ideal for overall wellbeing. The healthiest soda is one you don't need to drink too often or too much of!

Tips for Choosing the Healthiest Soda

When it comes to satisfying soda cravings, what’s the best option for reducing sugar intake? Here are some tips:

Cut back on full-sugar soda: Limiting intake of regular sodas with 30-40g of sugar per can is wise. The less you consume, the lower your sugar exposure.
Choose low-sugar varieties: Opt for sodas made with less sugar, around 6-12g per serving. This greatly reduces sugar while still allowing an occasional treat.
Add your own fruit: For homemade soda, add sliced fruit like oranges, berries, or lime to sparkling water for natural sweetness.
Drink soda over ice: Cold temperatures blunt the sensation of sweetness. This allows you to enjoy the flavor with less sugar needed.
Savor every sip: Instead of gulping soda, sip it slowly to fully savor the taste and need less to quench your thirst.
Select soda with added function: Seek out sodas with extra nutrients and nootropics for health benefits beyond just tasting good.

The verdict? Moderation and mindfulness are key, but choosing low-sugar sodas like BrainPOP makes satisfying soda cravings much healthier. Focus on quality over quantity, and don’t deprive yourself - just sweeten smarter!

Introducing BrainPOP - Soda with Less Sugar

At BrainPOP, we recognize that people aren't willing to fully give up the soda they know and love. But we believe there’s a better way to make soda: using less sugar. Our line of craft sodas contains only 6-10g of sugar per 12oz can, far less than the 30-40g in typical regular sodas.

We start with filtered carbonated water and carefully blend in natural flavors, a dash of organic cane sugar, and functional nootropic ingredients like L-theanine and vitamin D for an added brain boost. The result is a deliciously fizzy, flavorful soda that satisfies cravings but contains 75% less sugar than other leading brands.

Soda might never be the perfect health food, but by sweetening it smarter, we think we’ve created a tastier, lighter option that can be enjoyed guilt-free as part of a balanced lifestyle. We'd love for you to give BrainPOP a try and finally make peace with your soda cravings!

Back to blog